What If I’m Good at My Job but Don’t Want to Do It Anymore?
By Thomi Sechehaye
Someone mentions another project. Your name comes up immediately.
“You’d be perfect for this.”
You know how to handle the client. You understand the process. You can probably rescue the deadline. Everyone seems pleased with the arrangement except the person who will be doing it.
Being good at your job can make it difficult to explain why you’re unhappy. Your performance gives other people reasons to keep the arrangement going. It may also give you reasons to doubt your own reluctance.
Start by separating what you can do from what you want to keep doing. Then examine the particular activities and conditions behind that difference. You may find a reason to change direction, adjust your role, or investigate something you haven’t yet considered.
Competence has become part of the arrangement
Over time, work accumulates around reliability.
You explain difficult things well, so you become the person who explains them. You remain calm with demanding clients, so more demanding clients arrive. You can organise a complicated project, so somebody gives you a larger one.
There can be satisfaction in this. There can also be a point when you recognise that your calendar reflects what others need from you more clearly than what you want to contribute.
That recognition deserves some attention. You may still value the work and the people. You may also want a different proportion of activities in your week.
What research adds to the question
A review by Edward Deci, Anja Olafsen, and Richard Ryan examines workplace research through self-determination theory. It identifies competence, autonomy, and relatedness as important psychological needs. It also distinguishes motivation that feels personally endorsed from motivation experienced as pressure or obligation. Feeling capable is one part of this account of motivation. Having a sense of choice and connection matters too.
Applied to your situation, this offers several questions. Do you still value the activity? Do you have a meaningful say in how you do it? Do you feel connected to the people or purpose involved?
Those questions can make your dissatisfaction more specific. The research cannot tell you whether to leave your job. That decision requires information about your work, your circumstances, and the alternatives available.
Look at the activity inside the title
Imagine an experienced creative director who says, “I think I’m finished with design.”
Looking through a recent week, they discover that most of their time went into staffing, budget discussions, approvals, and sorting out misunderstandings between departments. They spent one afternoon developing an idea with a designer and enjoyed it.
This hypothetical example leaves several possibilities open. The person may want more direct creative work. They may want a different way of leading. They may want to leave the field altogether.
But they now have a better question than “Have I lost my creativity?”
They can ask which activities still interest them and whether a realistic role would allow more of those activities.
Make three lists from actual experience
The following exercise is an FFG application. Choose examples from the past month and make three short lists.
What I can do
Name activities you can demonstrate through experience. “Help a client turn an unclear request into a workable brief” tells you more than “communication.”
What I want to keep doing
Include activities you would willingly make room for again. Be honest about the conditions. You might enjoy teaching a small group with time to prepare, while finding a full calendar of presentations unappealing.
What I want to do less
Include tasks you perform well. You’re allowed to want less of something that appears on your list of strengths.
Read the lists together. Where do they overlap? Where does your current week give most of its time to the third list?
Ask what keeps you saying yes
For one activity you want less of, finish this sentence.
“I keep agreeing to this because…”
The answer might be income, professional reputation, loyalty to colleagues, familiarity, or concern about what would happen if you declined.
Give practical reasons their proper weight. Paying your bills and supporting other people are substantial considerations.
Then examine the assumptions within those reasons. Would declining one project damage your reputation, or have you never tested a more specific conversation about your workload? Could someone else learn the task? Does the role formally require it?
You may discover a genuine limit. You may also discover that an arrangement has continued partly because nobody has discussed changing it.
Choose one question to investigate
You don’t need to turn the three lists into an immediate resignation plan.
Choose a question that could affect your next decision.
“Could this role include more direct project work?”
“What would another employer expect someone with my experience to spend their time doing?”
“Would I still enjoy this activity with fewer interruptions?”
The answer may come from a conversation, a closer look at another role, or observing your own work for a little longer.
If you want a guided way to examine what you can do, what matters now, and what you might explore next, The Next Move offers a place to work through those questions.
Bring the work you know you can do—and the parts you would be pleased to do again.
Developed by Thomi Sechehaye, with ChatGPT assisting in drafting and editing for clarity and readability.
Comments